Review

Stargirl

The popular young adult book 'Stargirl' dives deep into the heart of a universal struggle: the challenge of standing out in a world that often rewards blending in.

Emma Baldwin

Article written by Emma Baldwin

B.A. in English, B.F.A. in Fine Art, and B.A. in Art Histories from East Carolina University.

It’s set against the backdrop of a conventional high school setting and delves into the profound impact of nonconformity. The book celebrates the spirit of those who dare to be different and the ripple effect they can have on a community. 

Jerry Spinelli is renowned for his ability to masterfully weave tales that resonate with the young and the young at heart. His reputation for addressing challenging topics in young adult literature shines through in this book. 

Plot Review 

The novel starts with the protagonist and narrator, Leo Borlock, entering a new high school. His existence is largely unremarkable, one student among many, until the school’s atmosphere is irreversibly shaken by the arrival of a new student: Stargirl Caraway. As Leo observes, Stargirl dances in the rain serenades students on their birthdays, and cheers for both teams at sporting events. She is incredibly different from everyone around her. 

As the book progresses, readers and Leo consider the innate human yearning to be one’s true self versus the looming societal pressure to fit a predefined mold.

Use of Characterization

Stargirl is, by far, the most memorable character in the novel. She’s an embodiment of nonconformity and a testament to living life as you see fit. Throughout the book, she’s unapologetically herself, whether that means playing the ukulele in the school cafeteria or leaving kind notes on strangers’ cars.

But perhaps her most defining trait is her endless kindness. She celebrates and uplifts everyone around her and manages to see the world with an optimism and wonder that is both refreshing and infectious.

Leo, the narrator, is more of your average high school student. He’s initially intrigued by her unconventionality, and Leo becomes a gravitational point in Stargirl’s orbit. However, he struggles to weigh his interest in her with his desire to fit in with his peers. This is something that many readers, no matter their age, are likely to relate to. 

Use of Symbolism 

Individuality vs. conformity is the primary theme at work in this novel. The book explores the eternal tug-of-war between the desire to be oneself and the pressures to assimilate. This theme is likely to resonate with anyone who reads the book, as every individual grapples at some point with the dilemma of self-expression versus societal expectations.

When it comes to symbols, Spinelli uses a wide variety to give the book depth and meaning. One of the most interesting is Archie’s house. Archie, an older friend and confidant to Stargirl and Leo, is a retired paleontologist with a vast desert backyard filled with bones and artifacts. 

His home is symbolic of the passage of time and the long view of history. In the grand scheme of things, Archie’s perspective reminds readers and characters alike that the trials of high school are only a fleeting moment in the very long expanse of time. 

Personal Thoughts 

The story of ‘Stargirl’ is the perfect novel for anyone about to start or start high school. This is especially true in a world increasingly shaped by digital media and societal “norms” dictating how one should look. 

We live in an age where online personas, influencer culture, and the quest for validation through likes and shares dominate the lives of many. In this contemporary context, the novel serves as a poignant reminder of the beauty and strength of being true to oneself.

Readers might find themselves questioning how often we alter our behavior, mute our opinions, or hide our true selves for fear of judgment. How frequently do we prioritize fitting in over standing out?

For young readers, especially, the story offers a powerful lesson. The trials of high school are universal. But Stargirl‘ champions the idea that our quirks and individualities should be celebrated. Embracing who we are, in all our uniqueness, is not a weakness but a strength.

Moreover, the story certainly underscores the fleeting nature of popularity and the true fickleness of public opinion. Really, lasting happiness and fulfillment lie in inner contentment and the genuine connections we forge with others.

Stargirl: Jerry Spinelli's Inspirational Novel for Young Adults
Stargirl by Jerry Spinelli Illustrated

Book Title: Stargirl

Book Description: 'Stargirl' is a highly relatable novel about the ups and downs of the high school experience.

Book Author: Jerry Spinelli

Book Edition: First Edition

Book Format: Hardcover

Publisher - Organization: Alfred A. Knopf

Date published: August 8, 2000

ISBN: 0-679-88637-0

Number Of Pages: 169

  • Story
  • Characters
  • Setting
  • Writing Style
  • Dialogue
  • Conclusion
  • Lasting Effect on Reader
3.1

Stargirl Review

Stargirl is a beautifully written novel that focuses on the trials and tribulations of high schoolers struggling to fit in.

Pros

  • Stargirl is a unique character
  • The book is highly relatable
  • The writing style is memorable

Cons

  • Unfulfilling ending
  • Limited secondary characters
  • Low-stakes conflict

Join Book Analysis for Free!

Exclusive to Members

Get access now

Save Your Favorites

Less Ads

Free Newsletter

Comment with Literary Experts

Emma Baldwin

About Emma Baldwin

B.A. in English, B.F.A. in Fine Art, and B.A. in Art Histories from East Carolina University.

Emma Baldwin, a graduate of East Carolina University, has a deep-rooted passion for literature. She serves as a key contributor to the Book Analysis team with years of experience.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Discover the secrets to learning and enjoying literature.

Join Book Analysis

Learn More

Share to...